A free report from Bad At My Religion

Find out where you're a hypocrite. (Everyone is.)

14 lessons from 22 conversations with people of every faith, and people who left theirs, about how they actually live it. From a Benedictine monk to a man who worked 25 years for Scientology.

  • PDF
  • 17 pages
  • 14 lessons
  • 22 conversations
  • Free

The PDF comes in the first e-mail. No card, nothing to buy.

From the host

Josh Galt III

I started this show because of a baptism party in Mexico. The Mass was beautiful, but the party after it was hours of Bad Bunny, drunk adults and kids high on piñata sugar, and not one person mentioned that the parents had just dedicated their child's eternal life to God.

I went home quite mad that I had wasted an otherwise perfectly good afternoon, and decided to start a podcast on the topic.

My premise was simple: people struggle to live by what they say they believe. I have seen both the hypocritical side and the pious side, and lived some of both myself. I grew up the child of Pentecostal missionaries, went all the way to agnostic, and came back to the Divine, though not to religion.

So I started asking people from every tradition, and people who left theirs, how they actually live it: a Benedictine monk, a rabbi, a Sufi, a Hindu who says there is no God, a former Mormon bishop, a man who worked 25 years for Scientology, a professor who has gone to church for ten years without believing a word of the doctrine.

For most of that time the line under the show's name was A quest to live any faith, fully. The more conversations I had, the more I had to rethink it. Some belief systems make the world better when people live them fully. Others, well, we know they make it worse. So now it reads An examination of living any belief system, fully.

The point was never to show how bad we all are at our religion. It was to find out how we can help each other be, and do, better. The report is what my guests have taught me so far: 14 lessons, each with the question it left me with.

Josh Galt III

What you'll learn

14 lessons, each ending with a question to sit with

  1. 1

    The question I now ask the kid before anyone cuts the cake at a first communion, and why it's the adults who squirm.

    From my first episode

  2. 2

    How I built worship sets to move a room while meaning every word I sang, and what a man who has meditated every day for 57 years said when I told him.

    From my conversation with Michael Hirtzel and Robert Forman

  3. 3

    Why a man who was a bishop at 29 and had read the Book of Mormon about 14 times says you can be a really good Mormon without being a great human being, and the grade the people you live with would give you.

    Bill Reel · Ex-Mormon

  4. 4

    The deal most of us make with God, and the sentence a Muslim convert never imagined she would say: "God made a mistake."

    Patricia Marin · Islam/Sufism

  5. 5

    What losing $60,000 on a business she believed God had put on her heart taught Amy, and the check she runs now before she acts on what she hears.

    Amy Chanthaphavong · Buddhism/Christianity

  6. 6

    Why a man who sold his house to race ten Ironman-distance triathlons in ten days ended up sleeping in his car at a truck stop, and what he says broke his pride.

    JD Tremblay · Christianity

  7. 7

    Why finding grace left a man raised in the Assemblies of God feeling "kind of dead", and the question he is still asking.

    Michael Hirtzel · Christianity (Assemblies of God, Evangelical, Calvinist)

  8. 8

    What kept a man in Scientology after he knew it wasn't what it claimed to be, and the letter that arrived on his birthday.

    Chris Shelton · Ex-Scientologist

  9. 9

    Why a man who never believed a word of the doctrine cried in church every Sunday for eight and a half years.

    Robert Forman · Transcendental Meditation/Christianity

  10. 10

    The one sentence from an old monk that has kept a Benedictine in his monastery since 1996, through more than one crisis about leaving.

    Father Augustine Wetta · Benedictine monk

  11. 11

    The practice a Hindu who says there is no God gave me for every night of 30 days, and the thing I'd do with my last 24 hours that I keep putting off.

    Arpan Patel · Hinduism / Vedanta

  12. 12

    Why the first Thai woman ordained in the Theravada tradition spent years waiting for someone else to go first, though ordination for women was her own subject as a professor.

    Venerable Dhammananda · Theravada Buddhist abbess

  13. 13

    What a Mormon transhumanist told me when I asked how we avoid the dark side of AI, and the smallest kind of forgiveness, which he says always pays off.

    Lincoln Cannon · Mormon Transhumanist

  14. 14

    Why "am I a hypocrite?" is the wrong question, and the better one I ask myself now, road rage and all.

    From my first episode, and my conversation with Gabriela Cruz

A look inside

17 pages, one lesson to a page

The report's cover: What 22 conversations taught me about living what you believe
The cover
The report's opening letter, with the show's old tagline crossed out
The opening letter, and the line I crossed out
Lesson 10: Be a good monk today. You can leave tomorrow.
Lesson 10: Father Augustine Wetta

What guests said during the recordings

“I just want to say for a second that this is the most fun I've had having a conversation in a long time.”
Father Augustine Wetta · Benedictine monk
“I want you to know you're very good at this, and you're doing a really good job. Your questions are deep thinking, and I really value this conversation and what you're about.”
Robert Forman · Transcendental Meditation/Christianity
“I'd call it a ministry in some ways: what you're doing to bring us together. It's really needed.”
Richard Ostler · Latter-day Saint

Lesson 3 of 14, in full

You can be very good at your religion and bad at being a person.

Bill Reel · Ex-Mormon · Episode 15

Bill joined the LDS church at 17 and was a bishop at 29. He'd read the Book of Mormon about 14 times. You could walk up to him three minutes before a meeting, tell him the speaker was sick, and he'd give a 20-minute talk. By every measure his church used, he was excellent at his religion. Then he told me this:

"I think one can be a really good Mormon without being a great human being. And I think I was definitely doing the former and struggling a bit at the latter."

At church he was doing everything right. At home he was stern with his kids and critical of everyone in the house. I started this show asking why we're so bad at our religion. Bill turned the question around. You can win every point your group keeps score on, and the people closest to you can still be the ones who pay for it.

The question

If the people you live with graded your closed-door example of living your faith, what grade would they give you?

Get the free report

The other 13 lessons are in the PDF.

Who it's for

  • You believe, and you want to live it better than you do.
  • You doubt, and you'd rather look at it honestly than drift.
  • You left a faith, and you're still working out what to keep.
  • You're spiritual but not religious, and curious how other people live what they believe.

Who it isn't for

  • You want apologetics: proof that your religion is the right one.
  • You want a takedown of religion.
Josh Galt III, host of Bad At My Religion

Who wrote it

Josh Galt III

I grew up the child of Pentecostal missionaries, and in college I helped start a church and led its worship.

Then I left, all the way to agnostic.

I came back to the Divine, though not to religion. On Bad At My Religion I ask people from every tradition, and people who left theirs, how they actually live it.

More about me at joshgalt.com

How it's sourced

Every quote is word for word

Every quote in the report comes from the recordings, checked word for word against the transcripts. Each lesson names the conversation it came from, so you can hear the whole thing.

  1. 1.Ask what the ceremony meant before the party starts.My first episode
  2. 2.You can believe every word you sing and still be working the room.Michael Hirtzel, Episode 12Robert Forman, Episode 19
  3. 3.You can be very good at your religion and bad at being a person.Bill Reel, Episode 15
  4. 4.If your faith is a deal where God owes you, the first "no" breaks it.Patricia Marin, Episode 4
  5. 5.Being sure God told you something doesn't make it so. Admit when you heard wrong.Amy Chanthaphavong, Episode 5
  6. 6.If your deal is "give me the win, then I'll give you the credit", the win was for you.JD Tremblay, coming soon
  7. 7.If guilt is what keeps you going, losing the guilt can stop you cold.Michael Hirtzel, Episode 12
  8. 8.Sometimes what keeps you in isn't what you believe. It's who you'd lose.Chris Shelton, Episode 16
  9. 9.You don't have to believe the words for the practice to reach you.Robert Forman, Episode 19
  10. 10.Be a good monk today. You can leave tomorrow.Father Augustine Wetta, Episode 13
  11. 11.What you'd do on your last day belongs in today.Arpan Patel, Episode 11
  12. 12.If you're waiting for someone else to start, it's probably you.Venerable Dhammananda Bhikkhuni, Episode 18
  13. 13.You don't have to forgive perfectly. Just a little more than yesterday.Lincoln Cannon, Episode 20
  14. 14.Don't ask whether you're a hypocrite. Ask where.Gabriela Cruz, Episode 3My first episode

Before you sign up

  • It's free. No card, nothing to buy.
  • The report comes in the first e-mail, a minute after you sign up.
  • After that, you'll get one e-mail a month from me with the new episodes.
  • I never sell or share your address.
  • You can leave the list any time: reply to any e-mail and I'll take you off.

Get the 14 lessons, free

What 22 conversations taught me about living what you believe. A 17-page PDF, in your inbox a minute from now.

The PDF comes in the first e-mail. No card, nothing to buy.

P.S. Some of these guests I agree with. Some I don't. All of them made me look harder at how I live. If you read only one lesson, read the last one: I wrote it about myself.

Josh Galt III